| 21 Mar 2025 | BIDDOCK FOLD, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Other | Freehold | £600,000 |
| 7 Nov 2022 | CHERRY TREE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Semi-Detached | Freehold | £375,000 |
| 11 Jan 2022 | HOPE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £350,000 |
| 4 Jun 2018 | HONEYSUCKLE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £270,000 |
| 27 Oct 2017 | THE OLD BARN, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £534,000 |
| 29 Aug 2017 | LITTLE LILAC COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Flat | Freehold | £223,500 |
| 6 Apr 2017 | NAGS HEAD COACH HOUSE, 3, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £217,500 |
| 17 Mar 2017 | NAGS HEAD COACH HOUSE, 2, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £270,000 |
| 19 Feb 2016 | BARGATE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £505,000 |
| 19 Feb 2016 | HOPE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £325,000 |
| 12 Feb 2016 | NAGS HEAD COACH HOUSE, 2, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £202,000 |
| 14 Feb 2014 | BRAY COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Semi-Detached | Freehold | £290,000 |
| 18 Sep 2013 | CHERRY TREE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Semi-Detached | Freehold | £208,000 |
| 12 Jul 2013 | INGLENOOK, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Semi-Detached | Freehold | £245,000 |
| 28 Jun 2013 | LILAC COTTAGE, 1, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Semi-Detached | Freehold | £275,000 |
| 5 Oct 2012 | FROGHOPPER COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £285,000 |
| 5 Jan 2011 | LABURNUM COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £205,000 |
| 26 Oct 2009 | FROGHOPPER COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £269,950 |
| 6 Jul 2009 | THE OLD WORKSHOP, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £230,000 |
| 19 Sep 2007 | THE OLD TEA ROOM, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £333,000 |
| 11 Aug 2006 | FROGHOPPER COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £275,000 |
| 23 Jun 2006 | LABURNUM COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £208,000 |
| 30 Nov 2005 | LITTLE LILAC COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Flat | Freehold | £185,000 |
| 26 May 2004 | THE OLD WORKSHOP, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £230,000 |
| 13 Apr 2004 | LABURNUM COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £187,500 |
| 24 Apr 2003 | THE OLD TEA ROOM, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £247,000 |
| 6 Dec 2002 | FROGHOPPER COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £167,000 |
| 29 Jul 2002 | HONEYSUCKLE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £130,000 |
| 25 Apr 2001 | THE OLD WORKSHOP, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £130,000 |
| 8 Nov 2000 | LABURNUM COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £87,500 |
| 3 Jul 2000 | HONEYSUCKLE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £115,000 |
| 17 Sep 1999 | OLD HALL HOTEL, MARKET PLACE, HOPE | Detached | Freehold | £536,500 |
| 12 Jul 1999 | MYRTLE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Semi-Detached | Freehold | £140,000 |
| 16 Jun 1999 | FROGHOPPER COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £115,000 |
| 26 Jan 1999 | NAGS HEAD COACH HOUSE, 3, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £78,000 |
| 30 Nov 1998 | BARGATE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £80,000 |
| 13 Nov 1998 | COSY COTTAGE, 1, MARKET PLACE | Semi-Detached | Freehold | £150,000 |
| 27 Aug 1998 | LITTLE LILAC COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Flat | Freehold | £90,000 |
| 16 Jul 1998 | INGLENOOK, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Semi-Detached | Freehold | £70,000 |
| 15 Apr 1998 | THE OLD WORKSHOP, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £77,000 |
| 30 Jan 1998 | NAGS HEAD COACH HOUSE, 2, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £88,000 |
| 25 Apr 1997 | LITTLE LILAC COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Flat | Freehold | £55,500 |
| 31 Jan 1997 | LEA HOUSE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Detached | Freehold | £133,500 |
| 31 Jan 1997 | FROGHOPPER COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £89,950 |
| 30 Sep 1996 | CHERRY TREE COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Semi-Detached | Freehold | £67,000 |
| 15 Jan 1996 | NAGS HEAD COACH HOUSE, 2, MARKET PLACE, CASTLETON | Terraced | Freehold | £77,000 |
| 6 Sep 1995 | BANK COTTAGE, MARKET PLACE, HOPE | Detached | Freehold | £83,000 |